FireMathLab

Overpay the mortgage or invest instead?

£200 a month on a £200,000 mortgage at 4.5% saves £27,475 and 58 months. Invested instead it beat the mortgage in 81 of 107 historical runs and lost in 26.

By Jobi·Published 10 November 2026·7 min read
This guide uses the Mortgage Overpayment Calculator.🏠 Open the calculator

You have £200 a month that is not spoken for, a mortgage that will outlast the decade, and a question that every forum answers with a shrug: overpay the mortgage or invest the difference? The shrug is partly justified. On the numbers below, investing wins more often than not and the mortgage wins every time, and which of those sentences matters more to you is not something a calculator can settle. What it can do is put a size on each side, and the sizes are not what the usual framing suggests.

Two assumptions carry everything that follows. The mortgage overpayment calculator holds today's rate for the whole remaining term, and fixes do not do that: they end, reprice to whatever the market and the Bank Rate look like at the time, and the comparison moves with them. And the investing side assumes money that is never touched. If you would raid the ISA in a bad year, the investing figures are not yours.

What £200 a month does to a £200,000 mortgage

The tool opens with £200,000 owed at 4.5%, a payment of £1,200 a month and a £200 overpayment, so these are the numbers on your screen already. Left alone, the loan runs 263 months, 21 years and 11 months, and costs £114,454 in interest. With £200 added every month it clears in 205 months, 17 years and 1 month. The term drops by 58 months, 4 years and 10 months, and the interest by £27,475. Over those 205 months the extra payments come to £41,000, so every pound sent early saves 67p of interest that was never charged. Most fixed deals allow penalty-free overpayments of 10% of the balance a year, which here is £20,000 against the £2,400 this plan sends, so the early repayment charge never comes into it. A lump sum can. Check the cap before sending one.

Timing does more than people expect. Five thousand pounds taken off the balance today, and nothing more ever, removes 11 months and £8,088. Overpay £200 for five years and then stop, say because nursery fees arrive, and the loan still clears in 240 months with £15,452 saved: 29% of the overpaying, 56% of the saving. The early pounds do the work because they have the whole remaining term to suppress interest, which is also why the balances-by-month chart under the tool shows the two lines parting faster every year.

The comparison the headline numbers invite you to get wrong

The tool shows £27,475 of interest saved beside what the same £200 a month would grow to if invested, and the temptation is to compare those two figures. They are not the same kind of thing. The interest figure is spread across the whole term; the pot is a balance at one moment.

The fair comparison is a snapshot at month 205. The overpayer owes nothing and holds nothing. The investor holds a pot and still owes whatever the untouched mortgage has left, which the engine puts at £61,524. So the question is whether £200 a month, for 205 months, grows past £61,524.

At 4.5% it reaches £61,018, just short. At 5% it reaches £63,884, just over. The break-even return is 4.59%, a shade above the mortgage rate because the site compounds investments monthly from the annual figure while the mortgage accrues at the annual rate divided by twelve, and the two conventions do not quite meet. At 3% the pot is £53,273 and the mortgage wins by £8,251; at 7% it is £76,994 and investing wins by £15,470.

Which brings up the error that quietly decides most of these debates. A mortgage rate is a nominal figure. The 5% the tool uses for the investing side is a real return, after inflation. Five per cent real with inflation at the Bank of England's 2% target is 7.1% in nominal terms, and 7.1% against 4.5% is not close. The two only look close when a real return is read against a nominal rate, which is what nearly everyone does. The reason to pause is not that the expected returns are similar. It is that one of them is guaranteed and the other arrives in whatever order the market chooses.

Following along? The Mortgage Overpayment Calculator takes the numbers from here.🏠 Open the calculator

107 runs through history

To see what that order has done, I ran the £200 a month through the same return history the site's backtest uses: approximate real returns for US large-cap shares, one figure per year from 1900 to 2023, which gives 107 overlapping 18-year windows for a 205-month plan. Each window got 2% added for inflation to put it in the mortgage's nominal terms and 0.5% a year taken off for fund and platform costs, and the pot at month 205 was set against the £61,524 still owed.

Investing won in 81 windows and the mortgage in 26. The median pot was £87,702. Start in 1983 and the pot reached £207,885, more than three times the balance it needed to beat. Start in 1904 and it reached £36,915, which is £24,609 short of the balance, and that is the figure to hold onto: in the worst historical case the investor was still paying a mortgage the overpayer had cleared, with a pot that would not have cleared it. Leave out the inflation uplift altogether, which is harsh on the investing side, and it still wins 73 of the 107.

The mortgage rate moves the count more than anything else you can type in. On a 2% legacy fix the overpayment saves only £5,885 and 32 months, and investing beats it in 96 of 111 windows. At 6% the payment of £1,200 barely covers the interest, so the untouched loan runs the full 30 years; the £200 then saves £79,447 and 108 months, and investing wins in 73 of 104. The history is American, the last seventeen start years are dropped because they cannot fill a window, and 124 years is a thin sample of 18-year stretches. It still says the thing worth knowing: the odds favour investing, the losing cases are not rare, and the bad ones land when the market falls late in the plan, which is the sequence-of-returns risk that the backtest exists to show.

Wrappers, tax and the pension wrinkle

The mortgage return is tax-free by nature. The investing return is tax-free only if you put it somewhere that makes it so. A stocks and shares ISA takes £20,000 a year in the 2026 to 2027 tax year, far more than £2,400, so the £200 belongs there before anywhere taxable. Outside a wrapper, gains above the £3,000 allowance and dividends above £500 are taxed, and the break-even return rises with them.

A pension changes the arithmetic rather than the tax. With relief at source a basic-rate taxpayer's £200 becomes £250 before it is invested, and £250 a month at 5% real over 205 months is £79,855, against £63,884 in the ISA and £61,524 on the mortgage. Even at 3.5% real the pension pot is £69,650, still clear of the balance. Higher-rate taxpayers do better again. The catch is access: if you are under 50 today, that pot is locked until at least 57 and taxed on the way out beyond the tax-free quarter, so it cannot clear the mortgage at month 205 even if it would have paid for it. The overpayment is not reachable either, since the money is in the house until you remortgage or sell, and the emergency fund calculator should size a buffer before either route takes the £200. An employer match still comes before all of it.

Choosing with the sizes in front of you

Against a 4.5% mortgage, the £200 a month comes down to this: a guaranteed £27,475 and a mortgage gone 4 years and 10 months early, or a pot that beat the mortgage in roughly three historical runs out of four and in the worst run fell £24,609 behind. The second option has the higher average and the first has no bad years, and plenty of people split the money and take some of each, which the calculator can model by halving the overpayment and running the invested half through the FIRE calculator. Paying the mortgage off has a second effect that calculator can show too: a plan without a mortgage payment needs a smaller pot, and the required spending drops from the payoff year.

Whatever you decide, do the deciding at your own rate, not at the one in the example. A 2% fix and a 6% deal give different counts, and if your fix ends in two years, run the tool twice, once at today's rate and once at the rate you fear. The overpayment walkthrough covers the lender side, which is where most modelled savings are actually lost: make sure the payment reduces the capital and the term, not next month's bill, or none of the figures above apply.